Firewire Versus USB
-
- Posts: 1454
- Joined: Tue Dec 11, 2001 4:00 pm
- Location: California
- Contact:
It isn't faster really -- 480mbps is burst, not sustained rate. FireWire is generally faster and uses less CPU. If you can easily get FireWire, use it.
Melodious Synth Radio
http://www.melodious-synth.com
Melodious synth music by Binary Sea
http://www.binary-sea.com
http://www.melodious-synth.com
Melodious synth music by Binary Sea
http://www.binary-sea.com
-
- Posts: 307
- Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2003 4:00 pm
- Location: Oregon
- Contact:
Since you already have a USB2 interface??? seems like you might as well test it... You can benchmark with HdTach from here: http://www.simplisoftware.com/Public/in ... est=HdTach
I would agree with Shayne though... given the choice, I pick firewire.
I would agree with Shayne though... given the choice, I pick firewire.
-
- Posts: 307
- Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2003 4:00 pm
- Location: Oregon
- Contact:
On 2005-11-03 19:03, braincell wrote:
According to HD Tach, my new drive is running at 31.9 MB/s and very steady. I tried all the USB ports and got the same results. The internal drive is 22.2 MB/s and very unsteady. Does this seem like USB 2 results or do I need to get the right driver? They predict SATA and SCSI to be way faster.
Now do the same, and compare CPU consumption...
Comparing USB2 to Firewire, you'll notice USB is slightly faster in theory (480mbps vs. 400mbps), but that's when the machine has nothing else to do. Let it run a sequencer (or rar or mp3 encoding, for the sake of benchmarking;) and notice which connection chokes.
I have such an external enclosure too, and only use the USB when the host has no firewire. The box has 2 1394 connections and I use it as LAN hub too - connecting laptop and desktop machine. Firewire has a much smarter chip: for example I can control my camera which hangs on the desktop's PCI 1394 card and comes to the laptop over the external enclosure, even when working in the desktop's BIOS.
In short, USB is nice if you want to store pictures, movies, mp3's IMHO, it's never been designed for multi-track audio.
Enjoy yer new harddrive, however you put it to use eh

more has been done with less
https://soundcloud.com/at0m-studio
https://soundcloud.com/at0m-studio
forget USB2
i 've done a test with an external HD box with USB2 and firewire connection .
with samplitude I've tried to read a 24 tracks project which is on the external disk .
with USB2 connection it was full of lag and with firewire connection is was perfect !
I need no more !!
PIV 3.4 ghz
1Go DDR ram
P4P800
winXP
i 've done a test with an external HD box with USB2 and firewire connection .
with samplitude I've tried to read a 24 tracks project which is on the external disk .
with USB2 connection it was full of lag and with firewire connection is was perfect !
I need no more !!
PIV 3.4 ghz
1Go DDR ram
P4P800
winXP